°±µÿï°°±ÿ¯ôÿ&{1SCHOLIA IN ARISTOTELIS SOPHISTICOS ELENCHOS €&QVIBVS CODEX VATICANVS VRBINAS GRAECVS 35 ORNATVS EST}1$ ¡¤á²°²±íÿ<20PERI\ DE\ ... E)LE/GXWN>20]1 €O( PARA\ TH\N U(/LHN H(MARTHME/NOS €<70A)NDREI/AN E)/XEI A)NDREI=OS XITW/N €P P €P>70 €O( PARA\ TO\ EI)=DOS €<70ZW=ON €P P €A(/NQRWPOS P I(/PPOS>70 €<70ZW=ON LI/QOS A)/NQRWPOS €P P €P>70 ¤á²²éÿ<20TW=N PRW/TWN>20: H)/TOI TW=N A)RXW=N KAI\ AI)TI/WN €E)C W(=N PA/NTA TA\ SOFI/SMATA ¤á²¶éÿ<20FAI/NONTAI>20: EU)EKTIKOI/ ¤á²·éÿ<20FUSH/SANTES>20: FOROU=SI GA\R I(MA/TIA POLLA\ KAI\ €OU(/TWS DOKOU=SI EU)TRAFEI=S E)C E)PITEXNH/SEWS TINO\S PARASKEUA/SANTES. €%3D%3 ¤á²·íÿ<20FULETIKW=S FUSH/SANTES>20]1 TOU=TO EI)/LH-€PTAI E)K TW=N, E)N TAI=S E(ORTAI=S GENOME/NWN. DE/KA GA\R FULAI\ H(/GOUN €GEITONI/AI PARA\ A)QHNAI/OIS E)TU/GXANON. E(KA/STH DE\ FULH\ E(ORTH=S GI-€NOME/NHS PROSH=GEN E)N TH= E(ORTH=. PRO/BATON EI)S QUSI/AN: I(/NA DE\ DIA-€BIBAZO/MENA TA\ PRO/BATA DIA\ TH=S PANHGU/REWS DOKW=SIN EU)TRAFH= KAI\ PI/-€ONA, E)FU/SSWN TAU=TA. KAI\ E)PESKEU/AZON W(/STE DOKEI=N PI/ONA MH\ O)/NTA €TOIAU=TA%10 _ %3D%3 ¤â²·±¶µá³íÿ<20O( ME\N ... SUMPERA/SMATOS>20]1 €<70ZW=ON LOGIKO/N A)/NQRWPOS €P P €P €P OU) P €LOGIKO/N OU) P A)/NQRWPOS>70 ¥á¸íÿ<20TO\ SUMBAI=NON>20]1 €<70DISU/LLABOS LEUKO/N A)/NQRWPOS>70 ¥á±·±¸éÿ<20TH\N AI)TI/AN>20: TH\N TW=N O(MWNU/MWN %3IB%3 @1 ¥á±¹éÿ<20E)PEI\ D' E)/STI TISI\>20: LU/SIS TOU= A)NTIPI/PTON-€TOS ¥á²²éÿ<20XRHMATISTH\S>20: W(S O( I(PPI/AS KAI\ GORGI/AS KAI\ €PRWTAGO/RAS %3IG%3 ¥á²´íÿ<20E)/STI D' W(S E(\N>20]1 TOU=TO FE/REI O( A)RISTOTE/LHS, €W(S A)/N TINOS EI)PO/NTOS: KAI\ TI/ O)FEI/LOMEN POIEI=N I(/NA MH\ PARA\ TW=N €SOFISTW=N A)PATW/MEQA: KAI\ FHSI\N EI) TO\ E)/RGON POIEI=S TOU=, KALW=S KAI\ €E)PISTHMO/NWS E)RWTW=NTOS EI)/ GE TW=N E)RWTW/NTWN EI)=. H)\ EI) TO\ E)/RGON TOU=, €KALW=S A)POKRINOME/NOU EI)/ GE TW=N E)RWTWME/NWN EI)=, OU)K A)/N POTE A)PA-€THQH=S PARA\ TW=N SOFISTW=N: TOU= ME\N GA\R KALW=S E)RWTW=NTOS E)STI\N E)/R-€GON, TO\ A)YEUDEI=N ME\N AU)TO\N H)/GOUN TO\ MH\ YEUDEI=S PROTA/SEIS E)RW-€TA=N PERI\ W(=N OI)=DEN. H)/GOUN PERI\ TW=N PROKEIME/NWN PROBLHMA/TWN. TOU= €DE\ A)POKRINOME/NOU KALW=S E)/RGON E)STI\N, TO\ DU/NASQAI E)MFANI/ZEIN TO\N €E)RWTW=NTA DIAYEUDO/MENON H)/GOUN YEUDEI=S PROTA/SEIS PROTEI/NONTA%10 _ %3ID%3 ¥á²µéÿ<20PERI\ E(/KASTON>20: PRO/BLHMA %3[1ID]1%3 ¥á²µé âéóÿ<20TOU= EI)DO/TOS>20: TOU= E)PISTHMO/NWS E)RWTW=NTOS €KAI\ TOU= A)POKRINOME/NOU %3[1ID]1%3 ¥á²µíÿTOU=TO DOKOU=SI KAI\ OI( SOFISTAI\ POIEI=N ¥á²¸éÿ<20TO\ D' E)N TW= LABEI=N>20: A)POKRI/NASQAI ¥á²¹íÿ<20GE/NOS>20: GE/NOS. TOU= SOFISTIKOU= LO/GOU O( E)RISTI-€KO/S ¥á³°éÿ<20TOIAU/TH DU/NAMIS>20: H( SOFISTIKH/ %3I#2%3 ¥á³°é âéóÿ<20OU(= TUGXA/NOUSI>20: TOU= DOKEI=N SOFOI/ %3I#2%3 ¥á³´éÿ<20EI)/DH TW=N LO/GWN>20: H)/GOUN AI)/TIA TW=N SOFI-€SMA/TWN. TA\ ME\N, GA\R PARA\ TH\N LE/CIN. TA\ DE\, E)KTO\S TH=S LE/CEWS. €%3I#2%3 ¥á³´³µéÿ<20PO/SWN TO\N A)RIQMO\N>20: H)/GOUN PO/SOI €TRO/POI TW=N SOFISMA/TWN OI( PARA\ TH\N LE/CIN GINO/MENOI. KAI\ POI=OI €OI( E)KTO\S TH=S LE/CEWS. %3IZ%3 ¥á³µéÿ<20PO/SA ME/RH>20: DU/O EI)SI\ TAU=TA: AI( SUNQE/SEIS €TW=N SOFISMA/TWN KAI\ AI( LU/SEIS. %3IZ%3 ¥á³¶³·éÿ<20TW=N A)/LLWN TW=N SUNTELOU/NTWN>20: €H)/TOI TW=N E# EI)DW=N W(=N STOXA/ZONTAI OI( SOFISTAI/. TOUTE/STI E)LE/GXOU €YEU/DOUS KAI\ TW=N LOIPW=N: %3IZ%3 ¥á³¸éÿ<20DIALE/GESQAI>20: A)NTI\ TOU= SULLOGI/ZESQAI %3IQ%3 ¥â´µíÿ<20E)K TW=N DOKOU/NTWN>20]1 H)/GOUN E)K TW=N KOI-€NW=N TW=N A)NAGKAI/WN GINW/SKESQAI PARA\ PANTO\S TOU= U(POKRINOME/NOU €EI)DE/NAI TH/NDE TH\N TE/XNHN. O( GA\R PEI/RAS XA/RIN LE/GWN PROSPOIEI=TAI @1 €MET' E)PISTH/MHS LE/GEIN. W(S DOKEI=N TO\N A)POKRINO/MENON A)LHQEU/EIN%10 _ €%3E)K_TE/XNHN: KA%3 ¥â±³íÿ<20E)/STI DE\ PE/NTE>20]1 €<70O( A)NTILOGIKO\S KAI\ FILO/NEIKOS LO/GOS €E)/LEGXOS YEU=DOS PARA/DOCON SOLOIKISMO/S TAUTOLOGI/A>70 ¥â±´íÿ<20PARA/DOCON>20]1 €E(/TEROS KORI/SKOU A)/NQRWPOS KORI/SKOS ¥â±´í âéóÿ<20SOLOIKISMO/S>20]1 €<70TOU=TO E)STIN LI/QON EI)=NAI €O(\ LE/GEI O( SWKRA/THS>70 ¥â±·éÿ<20O)/N>20: A)LHQE/S ¥â±¸éÿ<20MA/LISTA>20: H)/GOUN PRW/TWS ¥â²³íÿ<20TRO/POI>20]1 €<70TO\ SO/FISMA €PARA\ TH\N LE/CIN E)/CW TH=S LE/CEWS €&`1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13>70 €&Pro numeris arabicis, quos nos posuimus, haec habet codex: €&`1.$ O(MWNUMI/A &`2.$ A)MFIBOLI/A &`3.$ SU/NQESIS &`4.$ DIAI/RESIS €&`5.$ PROSWDI/A &`6.$ SXH=MA LE/CEWS &`7.$ PARA\ TO\ SUMBEBHKO/S &`8.$ PA-€RA\ TO\ A(PLW=S H)\ MH\ A(PLW=S &`9.$ PARA\ TH\N A)/GNOIAN TOU= E)LE/GXOU €&`10.$ PARA\ TO\ E)PO/MENON &`11.$ PARA\ TO\ E)N A)RXH= LAMBA/NEIN &`12.$ PA-€RA\ TO\ MH\ TO\ AI)/TION W(S AI)/TION TIQE/NAI &`13.$ PARA\ TO\ TA\ PLEI/W €E)RWTH/MATA E(\N POIEI=N ¥â²¸íÿ<20E)PAGWGH=S KAI\ SULLOGISMO/S>20]1 E)PAGW-€GH\N LE/GEI TO\ PARA/DEIGMA KAI\ O(/TI KA)\N E)K SULLOGISMOU= ZHTH/SHS, TA\ €E(\C MO/NA EI)SI/. KAI\ O(/TI TO\ DIA/FORON GINW/SKONTES E(CAXW=S, MH\ W(S E(\N €EI)DO/TES E)NNOW=MEN A(/PANTA%10 _ @1 ¥â²¸í âéóÿ<20SULLOGISMO/S>20]1 €E(CAXW=S €SUMBAI/NEI €GI/NESQAI €<70H)\ DUNA/MEI €H)\ E)NERGEI/A €H)\ FANTASI/A €TO\ DITTO\N €E)/XEI €PARA\ TO\ MH\ TA\ €AU)TA\ TOI=S AU)-€TOI=S O)NO/MASI €KAI\ LO/GOIS €DHLOU=SQAI €PARA\ TH\N €KAKI/AN €TH=S €LE/CEWS €GI/NETAI €TA\ PARA\ €TH\N €LE/CIN €SOFI/SMATA €P P P>70 ¥â³±íÿ<20MANQA/NOUSIN OI( E)PISTA/MENOI>20]1 €<70A(NEPISTH/MONES MANQA/NOUSI A(\ A)POSTOMATI/ZOUSI OI( E)PISTA/MENOI €P P €P>70 ¥â³´³µíÿ<20TA\ KAKA\ A)GAQA/>20]1 €<70A)GAQA/ DE/ONTA KAKA/ €P>70 ¥â³¸±¶¶á¶íÿ<20KAQH=SQAI ... PRO/TERON>20]1 €<70I(/STATAI €E)/STHKE A)NI/STATO KAQH/MENOS €P>70 €<70U(GIAI/NEI U(GIA/ZETAI KA/MNWN €P>70 €<70PTHNO/N KO/RAC O)/RGANON €P>70 €<70PTHNO/N A)ETO/S I)XQU=S €P>70 ¦á¶±´íÿ<20TO\ BOU/LESQAI ... LEGO/MENA>20]1 €<70BOU/LOMAI A(LW=NAI €U(PO\ TW=N POLEMI/WN €TOU\S POLEMI/OUS €BOU/LOMAI LABEI=N ME €E)GW/ €P>70 €<70GINW/SKEI O(\ GINW/SKEI TI/S TA\ GRA/MMATA €P>70 €<70GINW/SKEI O(\ GINW/SKEI TI/S LI/QON €P>70 €<70O(RA= O(\ O(RA= TI/S €KI/WN €CU/LON €P>70 €<70SU\ FH=S EI)=NAI O(\ SU\ FH=S EI)=NAI LI/QON €P>70 €<70E)/STI LE/GEIN SIGW=NTA CU/LA €P>70 @1 ¦á±·éÿ<20O(/TAN EI)WQO/TES W)=MEN OU(/TW LE/-€GEIN>20: W(S TO\ KLEI=DA. SHMAI/NEI GA\R KAI\ TO\ KLEIDI/ON KAI\ TO\N €A(RMO\N TO\N SUNDE/ONTA TO\N BRAXI/ONA%10 %3LZ%3 ¦á²³²´íÿ<20DU/NASQAI KAQH/MENON BADI/ZEIN €KAI\ MH\ GRA/FONTA GRA/FEIN>20]1 €<70BADI/ZEI KAQH=SQAI DU/NATAI €O( SWKRA/THS>70 €<70GRA/FEI MH\ GRA/FEIN DU/NATAI €O( SWKRA/THS>70 ¦á²¶íÿ<20KAQH/MENON BADI/ZEIN KAI\ MH\ €GRA/FONTA GRA/FEIN>20]1 €&[1`1]1 Ante correcturam:$ €<70BADI/ZEI KA/QHTAI SWKRA/THS>70 €<70GRA/FEI OU) GRA/FEI PLA/TWN>70 €&[1`2]1 Eadem schemata post correcturam:$ €<70DU/NATAI €BADI/ZEI[2N]2 KA/QHTAI SWKRA/THS>70 €<70DU/NATAI €GRA/FEIN OU) GRA/FEI PLA/TWN>70 ¦á²¶éÿ<20BADI/ZEIN>20: POTE/ %3MB%3 ¦á²¶é âéóÿ<20GRA/FEIN>20: POTE/ %3MG%3 ¦á³°íÿ<20MANQA/NEI>20]1 €&Ante correcturam:$ €<70MANQA/NEI NU=N €E)PI/STATAI €GRA/MMATA €O( SWKRA/THS €NU=N U(PNW/TTWN>70 €&Post correcturam:$ €<70DU/NATAI €MANQA/NEI[2N]2 NU=N €E)PI/STATAI €GRA/MMATA €O( SWKRA/THS €NU=N U(PNW/TTWN>70 ¦á³±íÿ<20E(\N MO/NON>20]1 €&Ante correcturam:$ €<70POLLA\ €FE/REI €E(\N MO/NON €FE/REI €O( A)LKIBI-€A/DHS>70 €&Post correcturam:$ €<70DU/NATAI €POLLA\ FE/REI[2N]2 €E(\N MO/NON €FE/REI €O( A)LKI-€BIA/DHS>70 ¦á³³³µíÿ<20TA\ PE/NTE ... E)/TI PRO/S>20]1 €<70A)/RTIOS KAI\ €PERITTO/S €DIAIREI=TAI €EI)S B# KAI\ G# €O( €PE/NTE>70 €<70I)=SON TW= €E)LA/TTONI €O(/SON TO\ €E)/LATTON €KAI\ PRO/S €TO\ €MEI=ZON>70 @1 €<70I#2# DIAIREI=TAI EI)S #2# KAI\ B# KAI\ G# KAI\ E# O( H#>70 ¦â³íÿ<20E)N ME\N TOI=S A)/NEU GRAFH=S>20]1 €<70A)PO/FASIS OU(= KATALU/EIS OI)KI/A>70 ¦â´µíÿ<20TO\ ME\N OU)>20]1 €<70OU) KATAPU/QETAI E)/STIN OU(= KATAPU/QETAI O)/MBRW TO\ TH=S PEU/KHS €CU/LON>70 ¦â±°íÿ<20OI( DE\ PARA\ TO\ SXH=MA>20]1 €<70DIDA/SKEIN E)NERGEI=N PERI\ TH\N MA/QHSIN TO\ MANQA/NEIN>70 ¦â±±íÿ<20TO\ A)/RREN QH=LU>20]1 €<70OU)DE/TERON €QH=LU A)/RREN>70 ¦â±²íÿ<20TO\ QH=LU A)/RREN>20]1 €<70OU)DE/TERON €A)/RREN QH=LU>70 ¦â±²±³íÿ<20TO\ POIO\N POSO/N>20]1 €<70OU)DE/TERON €POSO/N POIO/N>70 ¦â±³íÿ<20TO\ POIOU=N PA/SXON>20]1 €<70R(H=MA €TU/PTETAI ME/MFETAI>70 @1 ¦â±¶±·íÿ<20OI(=ON ... TE/MNEIN>20]1 €<70A)PARE/MFATON €TE/MNEIN U(GIAI/NEIN>70 ¦â±µéÿ<20TW=N POIEI=N>20: DUNAME/NWN %3NQ%3 ¦â²°éÿ<20PARA\>20: H)/GOUN OI( E)N TAI=S FWNAI=S PARALOGISMOI/ €%3CA%3 þ°±µÿï°°±ÿ¤¦â²±éÿ<20E)/CW>20: H)/TOI TW=N A)PO\ TW=N PRAGMA/TWN %3CA%3 ¦â²³íÿ<20A)LLA\ PH=I>20]1 TO\ POU=. KAI\ POTE/. KAI\ PRO/S TI, €ME/RH EI)SI\ TOU= PH= KAI\ A(PLW=S KAI\ TOU= ME\N POU= PARA/DEIGMA E)STI\, TOU=-€TO: OU) GA\R EI) PH=. H)/GOUN POU= TOUTE/STIN E)N TRIBALOI=S DOKEI= A)GAQO\N €TO\, TOU\S GE/RONTAS QU/EIN, H)/DH KAI\ A(PLW=S KAI\ EI)S PA/NTA TO/PON, A)-€GAQO\N TOU=TO NOMI/ZETAI. TOU= DE\ POTE\, PARA/DEIGMA TOU=TO: PA/NTES €OI( E)N TW= XRUSW= GE/NEI A)/NQRWPOI KATA\ TO\N H(SI/ODON, A)GAQOI\ H)=SAN: €OU)DEI\S DE\ A)/NQRWPOS E)N TW= SIDHRW= GE/NEI KAT' AU)TO\N A)GAQO\S H)=N: €PA/NTES A)/RA A)/NQRWPOI A)GAQOI\ H)=SAN: KAI\ OU)DEI\S A)/NQRWPOS A)GAQO/S. H( €LU/SIS TOU= SOFI/SMATOS. OU) GA\R EI) PH= H)/GOUN OU) GA\R EI) POTE\ ME\N H)=-€SAN OI( A)/NQRWPOI A)GAQOI/. POTE\ DE\ OU)K A)GAQOI\, H)/DH KAI\ A(PLW=S KAI\ €PA=S A)/NQRWPOS E)/STIN A)GAQO/S. KAI\ OU)DEI/S. TOU= DE\ PRO/S TI TOU=TO: €TA\ DE/KA PLEI/ONA: TA\ DE/KA OU) PLEI/ONA: OU) GA\R EI) PRO\S ...
frodomustdie